Murders Down 24%, Deaths at Police Hands Up
The Contradiction in Jamaica's Security Story

← Back to Latin America News

In the first half of 2026, murders in Jamaica fell 24% year on year, and shootings fell 27%. The government has presented this as proof that its security policy is working. Yet over the same period, fatal police shootings rose by roughly 25%. As of July 5, murders this year had claimed 275 lives — while one tally puts deaths involving the security forces at more than 110. Set the numbers side by side and a question surfaces. Does "fewer murders" mean citizens are actually safer? Or has the agent of the violence simply changed hands?

What happened

On June 10, police shot dead seven men in a single day across three parishes — St Catherine, St Andrew and Clarendon. Four of them died in a sweep through the Bog Walk Gorge, where police say they came under fire first from armed men. The Independent Commission of Investigations (INDECOM), the body that oversees the police, was as of June 9 investigating 143 fatal incidents involving the security forces since the start of the year.

What worries INDECOM most is the death toll of large-scale operations. Over roughly the past eight months, there have been more than 40 "multiple-fatality" incidents in which four or more people were killed. In January, the security forces shot dead 12 people in just the first five days of the year, prompting an immediate statement from INDECOM. April's fatal police shootings marked the highest single-month figure in three years.

Context: a different crisis — ransom kidnappings have doubled

While murders and shootings decline, kidnappings for ransom doubled between January and June 2026 compared with the same period last year. The very profile of insecurity is shifting. Overt, visible violence recedes into the shadows, and the "quiet terror" of kidnapping spreads. That can be read as a sign that organized crime is changing its revenue model.

Across Central America and the Caribbean, more and more countries are following the hard-line security playbook epitomized by El Salvador's Bukele government. Within that landscape, Jamaica is one of the few countries with an independent oversight body like INDECOM. That is precisely why whether that oversight functions effectively matters as a test case for the whole region.

The question: the politics of death statistics

The Jamaican government frames the drop in overall murders as a success of its security policy. The numbers themselves are not wrong. But if "the number of people the police killed" is left out of the reckoning, the very definition of success is distorted. In a democratic society, the state can hold a monopoly on violence only on the condition that its use stays within the bounds of law and proportionality. With 143 cases under investigation right now, no one can yet say with certainty that that condition is being met.

How the statistics are compiled is an issue in itself. Murder figures and security-force-involved deaths are counted and published separately, and the overall picture changes depending on which source you draw from. The figures "275," "more than 110" and "143" rarely appear on the same page — and it is only when they are placed side by side that the contradiction becomes visible.

My perspective

As someone whose work has involved evaluating policy through numbers, what this story brings home to me is how frightening it is that the choice of indicator decides the conclusion. Judged by the single metric of murder counts, Jamaica's security policy is a success. Judged by all "deaths from violence," including those involving the police, the verdict becomes far murkier. Add the doubling of kidnappings, and claiming that security has improved becomes harder still. Which indicator you choose is not a question of statistics — it is a question of politics.

If there is a redeeming feature, it is that all of these numbers are public, that an independent body — INDECOM — keeps investigating, and that the local press keeps reporting on it. A society that can be shown the contradictions in its numbers, as numbers, is at least a society where questions can still be asked. What conclusions the watchdog's investigations reach — that, too, is something we need to see through to the end.

Glossary

Jamaica is an anglophone Caribbean country, so this time the key terms are English ones. fatal shooting = a shooting that kills; when the police are involved, it is called a police fatal shooting. INDECOM = the Independent Commission of Investigations, Jamaica's independent body charged with investigating abuses of power by the security forces. ransom kidnapping = abduction for ransom, the category of crime that doubled in the first half of 2026.

To call a decline in murders a "success," you have to ask who reduced them — and by what means.

※ This article is the author’s commentary based on public information. Please confirm the latest figures, dates and procedures with governments and primary sources. Quotations are kept minimal and sources are cited.